Close This site uses cookies. If you continue to use the site you agree to this. For more details please see our cookies policy.


Type your text, and hit enter to search:

Keeping faith with ESG principles is hard to do 

The investment community has been keen to talk about environmental, social and governance investing but many have been reluctant to refer to ethical investing (“ESG: investors must stop trying to do the right thing for the wrong reasons”, Lex,, March 31).

It is refreshing to read Lex using the terms interchangeably but, outside the faith investors, today it is radical to do so. The mention of ethics implies choices. The current enthusiasm for ESG is welcome but some have been unwilling to say that being ethical can at times — and sometimes for long periods — mean lower revenues and profits than otherwise.

Russia’s war with Ukraine has shown that ESG cannot be divorced from ethics. It has also shown that a focus on ESG criteria, while necessary, is not sufficient. However, while activist investors might promise success, as Lex’s examples illustrate, they tend to focus on specific concerns with a company rather than its overall ethical approach. Activist investors professing ESG credentials face the same ethical challenge from the invasion of Ukraine as do other ESG investors.

First published in the Financial Times on 7 April 2022.

Financial Times letter, 7 April 2022, 08/04/2022

I have been involved with the Mining and Faith Reflections Initiative from the start. It brings global mining CEOs together with church leaders from around the world. The aim: explore how mining can better serve the common good.
Investors need to be clear what criteria they are applying.
Blackrock announced it is likely to support proportionately fewer resolutions on climate change this year. Makes sense but resolutions can change companies.
My assessment of the finance pledges at COP26 and what really matters.
Investors must not forget about profits, even as they focus on wider criteria.
Unless CEOs and their boards are clear about their own values, and those of the companies they run, they will fall down a rabbit hole of confusion.
Press announcement from the Central Finance Board of the Methodist Church.
My contribution to Aftershock, Policy Network's series on the pandemic. Progressives have much to learn from ethical or 'ESG' investors.