Close This site uses cookies. If you continue to use the site you agree to this. For more details please see our cookies policy.

Search

Type your text, and hit enter to search:

Making Labour the voters' choice on the economy

As we head deeper into 2014 it is vital that Labour improves its standing on economic policy. It is no surprise we have struggled to do this while in opposition, whatever policy errors this government has made (and they have been substantial in economic terms). Opposition is often a thankless task and it was always likely the economy would recover during this parliament. That this is happening should be no surprise – indeed, even the fact that growth is surprising on the upside should be no surprise to us, if that makes sense. Opinion polls point to rising confidence in the economic outlook and in government policy and with Labour still blamed for spending cuts. Of course we can and do argue that the recovery is imbalanced (it is) and relies too much on asset price inflation especially in housing (it does). We can also argue that the cost of living has risen for a large proportion of the population in recent years (it has). However, what we need to do over the next few months is demonstrate not simply that we are right about the economy, but that we are the right choice for voters for the years after 2015. Ed Miliband has the opportunity to do this by building on recent progress in his speech on economic policy tomorrow.

The UK economy continued to grow in December, according to survey data, with the Purchasing Managers Indices still signalling expansion. While industrial production data for November indicates that the pace of growth may have fallen slightly in the last quarter of 2013, forecasts of economic growth for this year are still rising. Unemployment is falling, with the headline rate at 7.4 per cent and the unofficial (though probably volatile) monthly rate at 7.1 per cent. Despite some uncertainty about interest rates, the overall picture at present is of continuing recovery. In fact the UK economy has been growing faster than we thought. Data revisions now show GDP growing 0.3 per cent rather than 0.1 per cent in 2012 and 2.1 per cent rather than 1.8 per cent in 2013, to the third quarter. Moreover, it now appears the savings ratio fell significantly last year as households increased spending. Overall, by September last year the UK economy was 2.0 per cent smaller than its pre-recession peak, but this was 0.5 per cent larger than previous estimates. The PMI survey data suggests too that recovery is being seen across most sectors in the economy.

Many people have not been feeling this, especially those on low incomes. Wage growth below inflation means real incomes have fallen. Yet the picture for discretionary spending might be a little different for some: mortgage costs have fallen, food and fuel inflation rates are lower than they were, and the personal tax allowance is higher. That means income that can be spent on discretionary items (things we don’t absolutely have to buy) has risen for many people. With inflation lower than last year and with rising optimism about the future, the perception is growing in households that things are improving. We can see this in opinion polling. This is the case even if the fall in real incomes has set us back many years. It is why the cost of living debate must not be solely about policies which deal with the situation as it is now. Labour’s campaigning on living standards is resonating with people, but to have durable credibility we must now say more about how we will raise productivity across our economy.

We need to be in government to do something about this, to ensure it is not only the already-wealthy who benefit from growth. To get there, we need to win the election and to do that we need a wide appeal. Ultimately, the party with the answers for the future is the one which knows how to improve the productive potential of the economy, can commit to substantially increasing investment to do so, and can show people how this will work for them. Investment in people, via education and training, and in infrastructure, and on a scale much larger than yet considered, should be the centrepiece of Labour’s economic policy.

This article was first published by Progress, on 16 January 2013.
 
Progress, 16 January 2016, 24/01/2014

 
Golden rules 
Labour is determined to show it cares about sound public finances. But to sustain its programme in government, it must show its vision for the future too.
The return of Mr Micawber: lessons of the Autumn Statement 
The scope for government economic policy has narrowed, but something has to change.
Government, gilts and growth: the Bank of England's dilemma
Government needs to say will reverse or postpone tax cuts if OBR says not sustainable. Bank of England should improve its communications.
Chaos and credibility
Why the Bank had to restore order.
Getting a grip - why Labour's own growth plans must be radical 
Labour has to challenge conventional wisdom to promote economic growth that benefits everyone - otherwise our public services will continue to deteriorate.
What will be the impact of the price cap on the economy? 
What matters most is our economy's productive potential. We don't usually get something for nothing.
Inflation and UK economic policy: some (obvious?) things to expect
A sketch of where we are following recent data. Some investment and ESG questions.
Inflation, the Bank, and the government 
The Bank of England's outlook in its August Monetary Policy Report was one of doom and gloom. It should ensure it is not captured by dated orthodoxy but ultimately government should act on cost of living crisis.